Skip to content

Home Topics Email Security Management Mailbox account takeover

Email Security Management · Mailbox account takeover

Email account takeover examples: what good and bad look like

Short answer

A good email account takeover implementation follows these steps: Enforce phishing-resistant MFA (FIDO2 keys or passkeys) for admins and finance; Review third-party OAuth grants monthly and restrict user consent. A bad one typically sMS-based MFA for high-value accounts.

Account takeover (ATO) is unauthorized access to a legitimate mailbox, typically via phished credentials, password reuse, or OAuth consent phishing.

What good looks like#

  • Done: Enforce phishing-resistant MFA (FIDO2 keys or passkeys) for admins and finance.
  • Done: Review third-party OAuth grants monthly and restrict user consent.
  • Done: Alert on impossible-travel logins and mass downloads.
  • Done: Have a documented response: revoke sessions, reset, audit rules and forwards, notify affected parties.

What bad looks like#

  • Seen in audits: SMS-based MFA for high-value accounts.
  • Seen in audits: Not checking forwarding rules after remediation.

How to move from bad to good#

Work through the good list in order and re-verify after each change. Most teams find one or two items from the bad list already present; fixing those usually produces the largest improvement.

Frequently asked questions#

What are signs of a compromised email account?

Unknown sent items, new forwarding rules, missing mail, login alerts from unfamiliar locations, and contacts reporting odd messages.

Keep reading on Mailbox account takeover